Will You Miss The BMW iDrive Knob?

Matt Posky
by Matt Posky

As part of the debut of the 2026 BMW iX3, we’re getting a glimpse of the updated operating system going into the brand’s “Neue Klasse” vehicles. However, the reveal didn’t just show us an upcoming model. It also serves as the death knell of the much-praised iDrive knob, which future BMW models will not receive.


Customers will instead be getting the Panoramic iDrive system (pictured below) — which is a buffet of haptic feedback and touch controls, supplemented by voice commands. While this trend has been commonplace among newer models, there’s not a surplus of evidence that customers actually enjoy these types of interfaces. Mercedes-Benz leadership even made a recent confession that giant screens and touch controls don’t really evoke a sense of craftsmanship.

However, the true issue is the fact that novelties of modern vehicle tech are wearing off. Most drivers have had an opportunity to experience both traditional controls and the modern alternatives at this point. Many are finding that the old ways are preferable from an experiential standpoint and there’s reason to believe they’ll age significantly better, too.


I’ve mentioned before that our household is presently in the midst of buying a new car for my better half and this has been a learning experience on what normal (relative to me) drivers actually want in a vehicle. While I’m sure my at-home rantings and ravings about modern automotive tech played a factor, touchscreens and haptic feedback buttons reside at the very top of her do-not-buy list.


Meanwhile, the infotainment dial found in Mazda products has been a big hit as we’ve browsed between brands. This isn’t necessarily because the knob is superior to traditional buttons. There are certainly instances where I’ve found it to be a less than ideal way to interface with the central screen. But loads of manufacturers have forgone physical controls in recent years, making it shine brighter by way of absent competition.


Mazda’s infotainment dial is effectively a dumbed-down version of the BMW iDrive knob, which was phenomenally intuitive and often considered among the best ways to interface with a modern vehicle. Despite some early hiccups, it has received a lot of accolades over the years and there is currently no shortage of outlets mourning its assumed demise. Here are examples of The Drive, MSN, Motor1, and The Autopian all singing its praises as it heads off into the sunset.

That’s not to suggest that the BMW iX3 (or other forthcoming Neue Klasse models) are horrendously designed. The automaker has intentionally tried to keep displays at eye level and allows for more customization than drivers ever could have dreamed of fifteen years ago. It’s also trying to make some of the decisions for you and hoping customers will let the advanced driver-assistance system (ADAS) do its thing without needing to fiddle with the options while on the road.


But, when drivers do need to make changes, they’ll be forced to utilize glossy panels that just aren’t as intuitive as regular buttons. The rest of the time, they’ll need to navigate the central display. While that’s not much of a chore when parked, it becomes significantly more bothersome when a vehicle is in motion. This has also encouraged BMW (and most luxury brands) to encourage drivers to utilize voice commands. But these have never been popular with all drivers, even though the technology has moved beyond the hilariously bad stage. Many voice systems actually work fairly well now. However, not all drivers want to have a conversation with cars equipped with a large language model.


We’ll see how the public responds and BMW has already been phasing out the iDrive knob in recent years. This included vehicles that weren’t developed around the new operating system, so the company seems to have faith that the knob’s utility has been exhausted.

Based on the upcoming 2026 CX-5, it looks like Mazda may likewise be doing away with the control knob as it brings in modern tech features and over-the-air updates. The entire market seems to be moving in the same direction and it’s allegedly very popular in China where large screens are indeed seen as peak luxury. But Western opinions are mixed and we continue seeing people bemoaning the latest vehicular trends practically wherever we go.


Development cycles are likewise fairly long and require massive levels of cooperation with suppliers, making it difficult for companies to pull an about-face on the hardware being implemented. But that assumes the desire of the manufacturer aligns with its clientele. With so much invested in modern tech as a potential revenue stream, automakers seriously want to convince drivers that software-defined vehicles with infotainment tablets and advanced driving systems are the best path forward.


However, we may soon hold a collective view of today’s tech-focused vehicles reflecting our opinion of the short-lived models from the 1980s featuring digital displays and voice alerts. Granted, the fairly realistic female voice coming from Nissan's Electronic Voice Alert was far more pleasant than the Chrysler system utilizing the same Texas Instruments voice synthesis chip found inside a Speak ‘n Spell. But customers of the day found that they all got old rather quickly and that digital displays tended not to last as long as their analog counterparts.


The end result is that automakers had basically given up on the tech by the 1990s. We cannot say with any certainty that the same fate awaits AI-supported voice assistants or tablet-like infotainment systems. But there is definitely a subset of our market that has placed them very low on their list of priorities. It’s just not obvious that they’re the same people buying from luxury brands like BMW.

[Images: BMW]

Become a TTAC insider. Get the latest news, features, TTAC takes, and everything else that gets to the truth about cars first by  subscribing to our newsletter.

Matt Posky
Matt Posky

Consumer advocate tracking industry trends and regulations. Before joining TTAC, Matt spent a decade working for marketing and research firms in NYC. Clients included several of the world’s largest automakers, global tire brands, and aftermarket part suppliers. Since adding automotive writing to his repertoire, he has become an ardent supporter of the right-to-repair movement, discussed the status of the automotive sector on national broadcasts, participated in a few amateur rallying events, and driven more rental cars than anyone should ever have to. Handy with a wrench, Matt grew up surrounded by Detroit auto workers and learned to drive by twelve. Alleged to be contrarian, Matt claims to prefer understeer and motorcycles.

More by Matt Posky

Comments
Join the conversation
2 of 10 comments
  • Mtb138493630 Mtb138493630 on Sep 07, 2025

    Offer both touchscreen and rotary dial. This way you please both crowds. But as usual, the bean counters cut every single thing out they can while raising the price and swearing they offer more content that is "better." My 25 x5 40i m sport is my last bmw until this neue klasse garbage design and infotainment goes out to pasture. Fortunately genesis seems to be content on offering both touchscreen and rotary knob as is in my 25 gv80 3.5t prestige. They also seem to understand design language in both interior and exterior and haven't gone with the ev minimalist garbage interiors a 'la tesla. Shame as the bmw 40i has a far better powertrain than the genesis 3.5TT..but the new interiors and exteriors of the bmws along with idrive 10/ os10 whatever they want to call it is all a deal breaker for me to leave bmw entirely. Id jump into a 7 series now but cant get over the hideous exterior and they are basically giving them away.

  • MQHokie MQHokie on Sep 08, 2025

    Kneejerk response as a 2023 x3M40i owner - yes, I will miss the dial. It's especially useful when I want to play a particular track on my 15,000+ track thumb drive - the ability to search by drawing letters on the dial face is great.


    However, I will give the new system a chance. If the upcoming iX3 will manage 300+ real world miles (i.e., highways at 80-85 MPH, hilly terrain, cold temperatures), it might be my next ride in a couple of years.

  • Jeff S Saw an older Mac Davis interview on YouTube in which Davis talked about his first big break was when he wrote In the Ghetto for Elvis and got a big check. Davis cashed the check and bought a new 450 SL and a large TV. Before In the Ghetto Davis was struggling and was close to giving up writing songs.
  • Bd2 what the world needs now is a new Ford F150 like I need a hole in the head
  • 6.2deadlifters the only good the orange underwear stain is goof for is raising EV adoption..
  • Ras815 Classy? Sure. But timeless, nah. The R107 really looks absolutely and unflinchingly of its time. No one today would ever mistake this being for a modern automobile.
  • Master Baiter An electric motor and reduction gear driving a vehicle's wheels is superior in every way. The problem is the battery--it's heavy, expensive, and it does wear out eventually. I'd expect an EV battery to last 20 years if treated properly. Battery power creates a scale problem--add battery to add range and you add weight, which in turns requires more battery to deal with the extra weight, etc... You can forget about EV pickups, and forget about an EV for towing, at least until batteries roughly double in performance, which won't be for 20 or 30 years into the future.
Next