Volkswagen Has Learned An Important Lesson About Buttons And Knobs
Volkswagen has seen sweeping criticisms for moving away from physical switchgear and has apparently learned a valuable lesson as a result. The brand has promised that future models will be reintroducing traditional buttons, including EVs prioritizing minimalist designs.
This is straight from the mouth of Volkswagen design chief Andreas Mindt, who recently told Autocar that the company is keen to correct past mistakes.
“From the [ID.2 and onward], we will have physical buttons for the five most important functions — the volume, the heating on each side of the car, the fans and the hazard light — below the screen,” stated Mindt. “They will be in every car that we make from now on. We understood this.”
“We will never, ever make this mistake any more. On the steering wheel, we will have physical buttons. No guessing any more. There's feedback, it's real, and people love this. Honestly, it's a car. It's not a phone: it's a car.”
While VW was among the first legacy automotive brands to truly embrace the current trends (e.g. all-electric vehicles and minimalist interiors devoid of buttons), this has become an industrywide issue. Automakers have leaned increasingly on touchscreens and spartan interiors because they’re cheaper to produce and the automotive sector has been laser focused on maximizing per-vehicle margins rather than sales volumes in recent years.
However, the above also meant Volkswagen was encountering pushback from consumers before a lot of the other brands. The increasing digitization of cars has come with all sorts of compromises, with vehicle control being at the forefront. Drive-by-wire controls haven’t been popular with drivers because they offer limited (and artificial) feedback, connectivity features have allowed vehicles to harvest information on their owners, and touchscreens have encouraged the industry to try and abandon physical buttons and knobs.
The latter issue has made basic vehicle controls much more taxing and have arguably sabotaged some otherwise sound car designs. For example, Volkswagen’s GTI and Golf R have long been considered one of the best performance values on the global market. However, the redesign of the Mk8 resulted in VW supplanting physical buttons and knobs with haptic feedback sensors and touchscreen inputs. They were broadly disliked and ultimately sullied the image of the related products.
Ironically, the haptic feedback “buttons” found on the latest VW models are significantly better than previous iterations. But physical switchgear is inarguably the best when it comes to ease of use and are likewise safer than touch controls.
From Autocar:
Mindt said VW will continue to offer cars with touchscreens, in part due to new legal requirements that, as in the US, will require all cars to feature a reversing camera.
“There are a lot of functions you have to deliver in certain areas, so the screen will be big and you will find a lot of HMI [human-machine interface] contents in the depths of the system,” he added. “But the five main things will always be on the first physical layer. That’s very important.”
We’ve heard similar statements from other automakers in recent months, particularly among the European brands. The design boss from Mercedes-Benz is now on record as saying that large touchscreens are luxurious in of themselves and that the brand would need to rethink how they’re implemented in order to impress their clientele. But we’ve seen plenty of automakers starting to rethink modern trends that, frankly, haven’t resonated with consumers.
Hopefully, the above means we’ll see car companies pivoting back to more traditional designs that are more intuitive. Volkswagen is certainly taking a step in the right direction. However, the fact that basically every brand sees automotive connectivity as highly profitable means that large interior screens will persist. Companies may say that modern vehicles shouldn’t be like phones. But they also intentionally designed them to be that way under the assumption that it would make money.
[Image: Volkswagen Group]
Become a TTAC insider. Get the latest news, features, TTAC takes, and everything else that gets to the truth about cars first by subscribing to our newsletter.
Consumer advocate tracking industry trends and regulations. Before joining TTAC, Matt spent a decade working for marketing and research firms in NYC. Clients included several of the world’s largest automakers, global tire brands, and aftermarket part suppliers. Since adding automotive writing to his repertoire, he has become an ardent supporter of the right-to-repair movement, discussed the status of the automotive sector on national broadcasts, participated in a few amateur rallying events, and driven more rental cars than anyone should ever have to. Handy with a wrench, Matt grew up surrounded by Detroit auto workers and learned to drive by twelve. Alleged to be contrarian, Matt claims to prefer understeer and motorcycles.
More by Matt Posky
Latest Car Reviews
Read moreLatest Product Reviews
Read moreRecent Comments
- Jeff S Saw an older Mac Davis interview on YouTube in which Davis talked about his first big break was when he wrote In the Ghetto for Elvis and got a big check. Davis cashed the check and bought a new 450 SL and a large TV. Before In the Ghetto Davis was struggling and was close to giving up writing songs.
- Bd2 what the world needs now is a new Ford F150 like I need a hole in the head
- 6.2deadlifters the only good the orange underwear stain is goof for is raising EV adoption..
- Ras815 Classy? Sure. But timeless, nah. The R107 really looks absolutely and unflinchingly of its time. No one today would ever mistake this being for a modern automobile.
- Master Baiter An electric motor and reduction gear driving a vehicle's wheels is superior in every way. The problem is the battery--it's heavy, expensive, and it does wear out eventually. I'd expect an EV battery to last 20 years if treated properly. Battery power creates a scale problem--add battery to add range and you add weight, which in turns requires more battery to deal with the extra weight, etc... You can forget about EV pickups, and forget about an EV for towing, at least until batteries roughly double in performance, which won't be for 20 or 30 years into the future.
Comments
Join the conversation
If the VW screen has menus, it's not good enough. If you're driving, you have no time for the distraction of flipping through menus for pretty much anything you would need to adjust while driving. Something as flimsy as touch screen electronics will be inoperable long before the drive train has reached the end of its useful life. Automakers are saving money by using all-in-one touch screens, but ensuring their vehicles will be off the road, too expensive to fix/replace the electronics, long before the vehicle itself needs to be replaced. In my line of work, that is known (in polite company) as ''wee-we-poor engineering''.
For 2025 Goofy VW brought back buttons on the steering wheel of the GTI and then stuck an iPad on the dash. One step forward, one big step backward. Many VW owners think the Mark 7 and 7.5 GTI were the best designed dash and control system. I have a 2019 Golf and a 2024 GTI and the 2019 Infotainment and HVAC controls are far easier to use. The 2019 and 2024 touch screens are integrated into the dash, not stuck on like an iPad. The good designers must have retired and now the twenty-somethings are in the sandbox.