Your $12,000 Used Car Now Comes With 98,000 Miles

TTAC News Staff
by TTAC News Staff

New cars crossed the $50,000 average transaction price last month and is likely to stay there for a while. Fortunately, we could always turn to the used market as the escape hatch. It isn't anymore.


A recent Edmunds study lays out the damage. According to Edmunds, a car in the $10,000 to $15,000 range now averages almost nine years old with roughly 98,000 miles on the odometer. Edmunds notes that back in 2019, the same money bought a car four years younger with 40,000 fewer miles. The budget shopper hasn't just lost purchasing power — the actual metal has aged out from underneath them.


Edmunds calls the broader shift "striking," and the numbers earn the word. In Q2 2019, cars priced below $20,000 made up 55.2 percent of the used market, per Edmunds. By Q2 2026, that share had collapsed to 31.8 percent. Cars under $15,000 fell from 31.6 percent of sales to 17.8 percent. At the top end, Edmunds reports the slice of used cars carrying a sticker of $50,000 or more grew almost fourfold over the same stretch, climbing from 2.3 percent to 8.3 percent.


Edmunds traces the root cause back to the production stoppages of the pandemic. Cars that were never built in 2020 and 2021 are the used cars that don't exist now, leaving a shallower pool for everyone shopping downstream. According to Edmunds, used prices have climbed steadily ever since, and there's no obvious mechanism to reverse it.


The three-year-old used car tells the story. Its average transaction price hit $32,461 in Q2 2026, a record high for the quarter—up 4 percent year-over-year and 15.5% from Q2 2021, when supply constraints first started inflating prices, according to Edmunds.

Here's the part that should worry anyone hoping for relief: buyers aren't pushing back. Edmunds reports that three-year-old used cars moved at the same clip in Q2 2026 as a year earlier, spending an average of 38 days on lots in each period. Dwell time says demand is holding firm even at record prices.


Which means the prices won't fall on their own. Buyers, so far, haven't reached their limit. The odometers, on the other hand, keep climbing.


[Images: Hyundai, Chevrolet, Chevrolet]


Become a TTAC insider. Get the latest news, features, TTAC takes, and everything else that gets to the truth about cars first by subscribing to our newsletter.

TTAC News Staff
TTAC News Staff

More by TTAC News Staff

Comments
Join the conversation
3 of 45 comments
  • D D on Sep 30, 2026

    "buyers aren't pushing back." because demand for cars is like demand for diesel fuel. There aren't enough alternatives to substitute for diesel for driving trucks. For much of the US driving is the only to get anywhere in a reasonable amount of time. Why? Because we refuse to invest in real public transit that serves rural and urban places. So the demand for cars is inelastic, meaning we will settle for more expensive, older high mileage car. In the short to medium term in the real world its not possible to live without a car. Sure, in the long term you might be able to move close to your job, and live in a city with transportation. But that is not the USA and it never will be the USA because we don't want to make any change that would make it easy to live without one. At least that's the policy of our current administration. And the Dems are not much better. They refused to increase the gas tax much for decades or invest heavily in rural intercity non highway transit.


    It's not like I want another car, I don't have any choice.

    • Hummer Hummer on Sep 30, 2026

      Why are you on a car enthusiasts news site if you're anti-car? No one would vote for a politician suggesting rural transit system outside of elderly and disabled care which most rural areas (at least here) have an abundance of. Plenty of walkable cities to live in for your type of lifestyle without incurring higher taxes on the rest of us for a net negative.

      The local city here has a fully setup bus system with free fares and by their own numbers the economic benefit is lower than the cost of the salary of the drivers alone. Factoring in the bus cost/maintenance, the encompassing system maintenance, and the bureaucracy running it - it's a huge net negative drain on our tax dollars. That's in an area servicing 150k people. Surrounding rural counties have population densities as low as 25 people per square mile.


  • Mic169855627 Mic169855627 on Oct 08, 2026

    No way out? Well in 1947 there were no cars on the market from 1941 on... Used cars were worn out. How did we do it then? The car companies made and sold GOOD LOOKING cars that were DIFFERENT from each other, ar a reasonable price to the average American. Starting in 1966 or so the car companies began to be pressured by the government to install systems by edict, and it never stopped. Seriously, find me a 4-door sedan without a big screen TV in the dashboard. Fins me one without a thousand nannies. Find me one that isn't computer tuned, controlled, tracked, or monitored. Find em one that I can repair, really repair, in my driveway. Find me one with reasonable horsepower, but not a turbo, not a screaming tiny four cylinder. One without a hybrid system that may work wonders but adds a ton to the weight and is totally unrepairable. I actually have or had all of the above. You know what I want? a 2001 Buick LeSabre with a 3800 V6, but since it's 25 years later, give me double overdrive, I want 30 MPG minimum, better on the highway! Yes the Hyundai Elantra can get nearly 50MPG without hybrid or a standard tranny, but the back seat is no good for a 6' human passenger. I want a pick up truck that hauls household stuff, not 13,000 pounds. Not an office on wheels, not a luxury sedan raised 3 feet off the road with a cargo bed, silverado I am looking at you! Even the new Ford Maverick (which should be a compact two door coupe) is way over "technified" Go simple. Price it right, sell a bazillion of them. Or the car co.s can continue circling the drain to the Kias and Byds.

  • 6.2deadlifters the only good the orange underwear stain is goof for is raising EV adoption..
  • Ras815 Classy? Sure. But timeless, nah. The R107 really looks absolutely and unflinchingly of its time. No one today would ever mistake this being for a modern automobile.
  • Master Baiter An electric motor and reduction gear driving a vehicle's wheels is superior in every way. The problem is the battery--it's heavy, expensive, and it does wear out eventually. I'd expect an EV battery to last 20 years if treated properly. Battery power creates a scale problem--add battery to add range and you add weight, which in turns requires more battery to deal with the extra weight, etc... You can forget about EV pickups, and forget about an EV for towing, at least until batteries roughly double in performance, which won't be for 20 or 30 years into the future.
  • The original ToolGuy™ INSATIABLE DEMAND!!! for used EVs lmao
  • Buickman my friend stopped by with his new Cyber Truck. I measured EMFs. Electric was in acceptable range, as was Radio. Magnetic considered safe at .4, it was 14.
Next