Tesla Buys Out Its Fire Truck Autopilot Case Before Trial
Tesla has once again avoided letting a jury decide who's at fault when Autopilot and the human behind it both fail.
According to Carscoops, the automaker settled with the family of Genesis Giovanni Mendoza Martinez, who died in a 2023 crash when his 2014 Model S struck a fire truck parked across a California highway. The deal landed less than two months before the case was set for trial on Oct. 26. Terms weren't disclosed.
The collision happened around 4 a.m. on Feb. 18, 2023, on Interstate 680, with Martinez driving and his brother, Caleb, in the passenger seat. Emergency crews were already working another wreck, and a ladder truck sat diagonally across the highway to block traffic. Other emergency vehicles were on scene with warning lights flashing. Martinez's Model S, running Autopilot, hit the truck. Martinez, 31, was killed; his brother suffered serious injuries.
According to the family's lawsuit and settlement, first reported by Law360, Autopilot had been engaged for roughly 12 minutes. Vehicle data reportedly showed Martinez generally kept contact with the steering wheel throughout.
A hand on the wheel is not the same as eyes on the road. Drivers remain responsible for controlling vehicles running Level 2 assistance, and courts have repeatedly said so. There's no credible evidence Martinez was intoxicated. What remains is the uncomfortable core of the case: a large fire truck sat across the highway with lights flashing, and neither the driver nor Tesla's software stopped the car in time.
The family argued Tesla misrepresented Autopilot's capabilities and that the system was defective. Tesla tried to toss those claims, but U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria let the misrepresentation claims proceed and found the "Autopilot" name itself "plausibly misleading." Tesla has always insisted Autopilot is driver assistance, not autonomous driving, and requires an attentive human ready to take over.
That framing was about to be tested in front of a jury. Now it won't be. When both the machine and its supervisor ignore something as loud as a flashing fire truck, apportioning blame is exactly the question a settlement lets everyone skip.
[Images: Contra Costa County Fire Department ]
Become a TTAC insider. Get the latest news, features, TTAC takes, and everything else that gets to the truth about cars first by subscribing to our newsletter.
More by TTAC News Staff
Latest Car Reviews
Read moreLatest Product Reviews
Read moreRecent Comments
- The original ToolGuy™ INSATIABLE DEMAND!!! for used EVs lmao
- Buickman my friend stopped by with his new Cyber Truck. I measured EMFs. Electric was in acceptable range, as was Radio. Magnetic considered safe at .4, it was 14.
- Jude Timeless? Not in my opinion. This and its Pagoda predecessor are stuck in their times (Pagoda looked older than the year it debuted). The R129 is timeless.
- Gregg Mulry I don't understand all the animosity toward start-stop systems. The one on my 2018 Volvo has worked flawlessly for going on nine years. I guess the first couple of times it was disconcerting, but once I realized pushing on the gas to go moved the car just as quickly forward as if the engine were still running, I therefore had no more concern. Now, I did have a friend with a BMW where the start-stop system seemed less smooth, but newer 48 volt systems have smoothed out the operation from some of those older versions. I don't need my car to idles while stopped. If you do, turn the feature off. But don't take the system away from me.
- KwikShiftPro4X I would not buy a used EV. I would rather begin fresh and ensuring proper charging habits to maximize the battery's lifespan and minimize charge degradation. Plus warranty in case some gremlins show up.
Comments
Join the conversation
I don't think this would have got past the motion to dismiss if Tesla hadn't named its systems "Autopilot" and "Full Self-Driving."
Tesla settled for marketing reasons.
Tesla would have (and should have) won if this had gone to trial, based on the technical merits of the case. SAE Level 2 autonomy clearly requires driver vigilance at all times. This means it doesn't even have to work.
But I suspect they settled merely to keep using the "Autopilot" name. A change of name would be an admission of guilt in the court of public opinion, potentially opening a flood of meritless lawsuits that the company just doesn't want to deal with.
The fire trucks were there because of an earlier accident and if all of you would learn to drive like I keep telling you, none of this would have ever happened.
Also, your grandmother would like to remind you that nothing good happens on the roads at 4 AM. Your car should be safely home well before then.