'I Won': Man Becomes Woman to Score Cheaper Chevy Cruze Insurance Policy

Steph Willems
by Steph Willems

Why didn’t I think of this? An Alberta man with a spotty driving record and a burning lust for the Chevrolet Cruze discovered you can save piles of cash if the government thinks you’re a woman. Or at least an individual who identifies as one.

Speaking anonymously to CBC, the man said his transition to a female (on paper) began after he approached insurance companies in search of coverage for his new — and quite sensible — compact sedan. Well, we assume it was the sedan.

What followed was a journey through genders, all to save 91 bucks a month.

Hot for Cruze, the man, then 23, soon discovered his driving past meant paying a Traverse-sized premium. It’s no secret that young people, guys especially, pose a risk to insurers, thus leaving them paying more for coverage. (Your author recalls recoiling in horror after getting a quote on an ’88 Mustang LX four-cylinder.)

One accident and two tickets meant the first insurer he spoke with quoted him $4,500. Ouch! In passing, the man, whom the news outlet refers to as David, asked what the reduction would be if he was a woman. It turns out that a lady David would pay $3,400 a year, leaving him with a cool $1,100 in his bank account.

“I was pretty angry about that,” he told Canada’s national broadcaster. “And I didn’t feel like getting screwed over any more.”

And so, like the protagonist in the Lou Reed song, he became a she. “David” learned that if he changed his gender on his birth certificate and driver’s license, he could qualify for the cheaper policy. But first, he required a doctor’s note.

“It was pretty simple,” he said. “I just basically asked for it and told them that I identify as a woman, or I’d like to identify as a woman, and he wrote me the letter I wanted.”

Had he waited until June, David wouldn’t have needed to visit the MD. Alberta recently scrapped the law requiring a doctor’s note before individuals can change their gender on government documents.

“I was quite shocked, but I was also relieved,” David said. “I felt like I beat the system. I felt like I won.”

With a driver’s license displaying his new gender in hand, David returned to his broker and got the policy he wanted. He also got the Cruze of his dreams. The Alberta man claims he didn’t go through this in order to cast aspersions at transgendered folk or the process of legally changing one’s gender. No, this was all about the insurance, he said, adding that he’s still all man.

We have to assume the Pride of Lordstown had something to do with it, too.

Having gamed the system, David’s sitting pretty. But he might not be the only man to undergo a sex change of sorts in order to lower his insurance costs. Steve Kee, spokesman for the Insurance Bureau of Canada, told CBC that he’s heard “anecdotal” reports of other individuals doing the same thing — though with savings comes danger.

“If you’re going to declare on any document, you need to be truthful,” Kee said. “If not, you’re making a fraudulent claim. This could impact you for any future insurance application that you make, or any other aspect of your life.”

[Image: © Bozi Tatarevic/The Truth About Cars]

Steph Willems
Steph Willems

More by Steph Willems

Comments
Join the conversation
3 of 48 comments
  • HotPotato HotPotato on Jul 29, 2018

    Lol@ “burning lust for the Chevrolet Cruze” Yes, it sucks to be a male under 25 shopping for car insurance, because apparently statistically men under 25 drive like a-holes. Hence this and other less extreme workarounds, e.g. registering the car to Mom and identifying her as the primary driver. On the one hand, the disparity kind of makes a mockery of the point of insurance: to pool and dilute risk. On the other hand, car insurance is not health insurance; I suppose driving a beater for a few years instead of a new car won’t kill you.

  • El scotto El scotto on Jul 29, 2018

    I would imagine statistically, that under 25yo women say; "Here, hold my beer" much less than their under under 25yo male counterparts

    • Art Vandelay Art Vandelay on Jul 30, 2018

      They are also statistically more likely to say "I need a month off since I'm having a baby" then men but people get pretty upset when you pay them less money because of that. This is sexism, pure and simple.

  • Forward Observer The last time I had a door off my truck I hung it from my Little Giant ladder. But I was only replacing the hinge pins.I'm sorry if this sounds smarmy or smug, I am working on my people skills. (My therapist says I have a long way to go to catch up with some of you.) Would smarmy and smug come in handy if I worked for an automotive dealership? (I wonder.)
  • Arthur Dailey Auto 'journalists' should stop referencing the average new car purchase price and instead report on the mean price. We all understand that the glue of luxury vehicles and full size pickups inflate the average price.For me, 'affordable' hovers around the $35k mark.Under current N.A. standards, hatchbacks, stations wagons and non-luxury coupes are basically a lost cause.Personally I would like to see Canada convert to accepting vehicles that have passed the European standards, rather than adhering only to N.A. standards. That would allow for the importation of vehicles such as Dacias, Skodas, and yes more Fiats. Also some models for Japanese and Korean manufacturers that currently are not sold in North America. It may even help Mitsubishi in the Canadian market and allow for the return of Suzuki. Having more small, affordable vehicles available is not a bad thing.
  • The original ToolGuy™ Doubt we will see any new vehicle in the low 20s unless it is an EV and Chinese but wouldn't count on that happening. Not against more affordable vehicles but don't foresee that happening in the immediate future.Jeffs do you do any research before making ignorant comments? We have brand new vehicles sold today in the low 20s including the Hyundai Venue that starts at $20,550.
  • KwikShiftPro4X That ship has sailed. The new overvalued cheap/base car will be $30G.
  • The original ToolGuy™ We have inexpensive cars already
Next