15 Toyotas That Aren't As Reliable as The Rest
2010 Toyota Prius
Average Annual Maintenance/Repair Cost: ~$552 (major repairs run $1,500–$3,500) The Problems: The 2010 Prius holds the highest number of NHTSA braking complaints of any modern Toyota. Owners reported a momentary loss of braking power over bumpy surfaces due to ABS software and failing brake booster pump assemblies. Higher-mileage units also suffer from clogged Exhaust Gas Recirculation (EGR) coolers, which cause cylinder overheating and blown head gaskets ($1,800–$3,000). Recall Status: Recalled for ABS software updates (10V-039), brake booster pump assemblies (13V-235), and unintended acceleration floor-mat interference.
2009 Toyota Corolla
Average Annual Maintenance/Repair Cost: ~$517 The Problems: The 2009 Corolla was plagued by two overlapping issues: early water pump failures around 60,000 miles ($450–$800) and severe oil burning on models equipped with the optional 2.4L 4-cylinder engine (up to $4,500 for piston ring replacement). Standard 1.8L models also frequently suffered from rattling variable valve timing (VVT-i) cam gears on cold starts. Recall Status: Subject to Takata airbag inflator recalls, sticky accelerator pedal campaigns, and defective engine control modules (ECMs) on early-build units.
2011 Toyota Sienna
Average Annual Maintenance/Repair Cost: ~$600–$900 (higher for AWD models) The Problems: The 2011 Sienna had widespread failures of its power sliding doors—frayed cables and burned-out motors cost $1,600+ out of pocket—as well as rupturing rubber engine oil cooler lines that can dump the engine's oil in seconds ($1,450 repair). All-wheel-drive models also experience premature rear differential bearing failure around 95,000 miles ($1,800–$2,500). Recall Status: Recalled for Takata front passenger airbags (19V-005), sliding door latch defects (G04), and shifting out of park without depressing the brake.
2008 Toyota RAV4 (4-cyl)
Average Annual Maintenance/Repair Cost: ~$500–$650 The Problems: Like the 2007 Camry, the 4-cylinder 2008 RAV4 used the 2.4L 2AZ-FE engine prone to severe oil consumption from clogged piston oil-return holes. Beyond oil burning, owners frequently faced intermediate steering shaft clunks ($350–$500) and failing viscous couplers on AWD models ($1,200+). Recall Status: Recalled for rear suspension lower arm corrosion/separation and window master switch fire hazards.
2010 Toyota Corolla
Average Annual Maintenance/Repair Cost: ~$517 The Problems: The 2010 Corolla recorded over 4,400 NHTSA complaints, heavily concentrated around electrical and safety systems. Common out-of-warranty failures include airbag clockspring/spiral cable breaks (disabling the horn and steering wheel controls, ~$450), alternator bearing failures, and premature water pump leaks. Recall Status: Recalled for Takata front passenger airbag inflators (18V-024), airbag spiral cable assemblies (14V-168), and accelerator pedal entrapment.
2007 Toyota Camry (4-Cyl)
Average Annual Maintenance/Repair Cost: ~$450–$600 (piston ring rebuilds average $2,400–$4,500) The Problems: Equipping the 2007 Camry with the 2AZ-FE 2.4L engine resulted in one of Toyota’s most notorious mechanical flaws: poorly designed low-tension piston rings that allow oil to seep into the combustion chamber. Affected cars burn up to a quart of oil every 500–1,000 miles, leading to catalytic converter failure and engine starvation if not constantly topped off. Recall Status: Never issued as a safety recall, though Toyota ran a 10-year/150,000-mile Warranty Enhancement Program (ZE7) that has since expired.
2011 Toyota 4Runner
Average Annual Maintenance/Repair Cost: ~$502–$785 The Problems: While the fifth-generation 4Runner is renowned for longevity, the 2011 model year logged over 1,000 NHTSA complaints—primarily tied to safety recalls—alongside mechanical wear items like failing secondary air injection pumps ($1,200–$1,800), seized front brake calipers, and aging X-REAS hydraulic suspension leaks on Limited trims ($2,000+ to replace). Recall Status: Covered under Takata passenger airbag inflator recalls and brake override software campaigns.
2016 Toyota Tacoma
Average Annual Maintenance/Repair Cost: ~$760 The Problems: The launch year for the third-generation Tacoma struggled with erratic shifting and gear-hunting from its new 6-speed automatic transmission, exacerbated by trucks leaving the factory with low transmission fluid. It also suffered from failing crankshaft position sensors (causing sudden stalls), weeping rear differentials, and premature leaf-spring failure. Recall Status: Recalled for crankshaft position sensor corrosion and rear differential oil leaks that could seize the rear axle.
2018 Toyota Camry
Average Annual Maintenance/Repair Cost: ~$594 The Problems: Introducing a new 8-speed automatic transmission, the 2018 Camry drew over 4,800 powertrain complaints for harsh shifting, delayed acceleration from a stop, and premature transmission wear. Owners also reported sudden loss of power-brake assist due to a failing vacuum pump vane and engine stalling from faulty fuel pumps. Recall Status: Covered under Recall 20V-012 (fuel pump) and Recall 21V-890 (power brake assist vacuum pump).
2019 Toyota RAV4
Average Annual Maintenance/Repair Cost: ~$647 The Problems: The first year of the fifth-generation redesign racked up nearly 5,000 NHTSA complaints—more than any other single RAV4 model year. Key issues include a defective Denso low-pressure fuel pump that causes the engine to stall without warning, premature failure of the 8-speed automatic transmission ($6,800–$8,100 to replace), and water leaks through roof-rail mounting clips that damage headliners and curtain airbags. Recall Status: Fuel pump failures are covered under Recall 20V-682, and Toyota issued a Customer Support Program to fix the roof-rail leaks.
2021 Toyota Highlander
Average Annual Maintenance/Repair Cost: ~$689 (transmission replacement runs $8,800–$14,000+) The Problems: The 2021 Highlander generated over 3,400 NHTSA powertrain complaints centered on the UA80 8-speed automatic transmission. A manufacturing defect in the transmission's pinion shaft nut/bearing causes a high-pitched whine during deceleration around 60,000–80,000 miles, eventually resulting in complete internal transmission failure just outside the factory powertrain warranty. Recall Status: No formal recall has been issued for the transmission; Toyota addressed it only via Technical Service Bulletins (TSB-0008-21).
2022 Toyota Tundra
Average Annual Maintenance/Repair Cost: ~$650–$750 (out-of-warranty engine failures exceed $18,000–$30,000) The Problems: As the debut year for the third-generation Tundra, the 2022 model suffered from machining debris left inside the new 3.4L twin-turbo V6 engine during manufacturing, leading to main bearing failure, knocking, and sudden engine seizure. It also drew recalls for rear axle shaft nuts loosening, fuel line leaks (fire risk), and transmission software allowing the truck to creep in neutral. Recall Status: Covered under massive Safety Recall 24TA07, which requires full long-block engine replacements at no cost to owners.
2023 Toyota bZ4X
Average Annual Maintenance/Repair Cost: ~$450–$550 (heat pump/compressor repairs run $3,500–$9,000 out of warranty) The Problems: Toyota's first mass-market battery-electric SUV suffered a rocky launch marked by a stop-sale order after hub bolts were found to loosen under normal driving, risking wheel detachment. Owners also reported sluggish DC fast-charging in cold weather and heat-pump A/C compressor seizures that disable cabin defrosting. Recall Status: Covered under Recall 22V-444 (wheel hub bolts and wheel replacement), Recall 25V-577 (HVAC compressor/defroster failure), and Recall 26V-393 (battery ECU memory conflict).
2024 Toyota Grand Highlander
Average Annual Maintenance/Repair Cost: ~$650–$700 (projected) The Problems: As an all-new three-row nameplate for 2024, the Grand Highlander experienced early production teething issues, including a multi-month stop-sale due to side curtain airbags failing to deploy properly when windows were rolled down. Early owners have also reported software glitches in the digital instrument cluster and rough shifting in non-hybrid 2.4L turbo models. Recall Status: Subject to Safety Recall 24V-461 to replace both driver and passenger side curtain shield airbag assemblies.
2006 Toyota Tacoma
Average Annual Maintenance/Repair Cost: ~$760 (frame replacement exceeds $10,000 if uncovered) The Problems: While mechanically durable, the 2006 Tacoma is notorious for severe frame perforation caused by inadequate corrosion protection inside the boxed frame rails. Left unchecked, rust compromises suspension mounting points, leaf springs, and brake lines, rendering the truck unsafe to drive. Recall Status: Addressed via a massive class-action settlement and Limited Service Campaign (ZH6) that replaced frames free of charge within 12 years of the first-use date—meaning coverage has expired for all units today.